Lyrics

[Verse 1]
You came in like Sunday morning
Coffee on your sleeve
Late again
Laughing at the wrong punchline
Like you’d always known my friends
You asked if I believed in chances
I said
“Only when they don’t make sense”
You smiled like you’d been waiting
On the other side of the fence
[Pre-Chorus]
And every scar
Started glowing
When you said my name
Like you’d been knowing
[Chorus]
Take my hand
Welcome to my secondhand heaven
It’s a little cracked
A little torn
But it’s open
I was saving all my broken
Hoping
Hiding
Now your heart fits mine like it was always meant to
In this secondhand heaven
I’m brand new with you (oh)
[Verse 2]
We dance on a crooked carpet
Bare feet in your old band tee
You swear that you can’t sing in tune
But you’re hitting every note in me
We talk about the almost-forevers
All the doors we slammed too soon
You say you’re scared of happy endings
I say
“Let’s just start at the middle
You”
[Pre-Chorus]
And every doubt
Starts collapsing
When you pull me close
Like it’s all just happening
[Chorus]
Take my hand
Welcome to my secondhand heaven
It’s a little cracked
A little torn
But it’s open
I was saving all my broken
Hoping
Hiding
Now your heart fits mine like it was always meant to
In this secondhand heaven
I’m brand new with you (yeah, yeah)
[Bridge]
If we fall
Then let it be together
If we burn
We’ll light up all the dark
I don’t need a perfect-ever-after
Just your name
Written next to my heart (oh)
[Verse 3]
You find all the faded letters
Folded in my drawers
Dust and ink
Stories I could never finish
Thought they’d always be
The end of me
You trace every almost-promise
Every line
I tried to hide
You say, “Look, they led you to me
Every wrong turn
Pulled you to my side”
[Pre-Chorus]
And every loss
Starts to matter
When you say, “Those roads
Just led you here faster”
[Chorus]
Take my hand
Welcome to my secondhand heaven
It’s a little cracked
A little torn
But it’s open
I was saving all my broken
Hoping
Hiding
Now your heart fits mine like it was always meant to
In this secondhand heaven
I’m brand new with you (oh, oh)
[Bridge 2]
All the chipped gold frames
On my bedroom wall
Every old love’s face
That I can’t recall
You turn them straight
So they stop their sway
Say, “They’re proof you chose
To stay, to stay” (yeah)
[Verse 4]
You hang up your worn-out jacket
Next to all my ghosts
Let them stare
At the way you hold me steady
Like you always knew
You’d find me there
We laugh at the broken picture
All the cracks
Across the glass
You say, “Baby, every fracture
Made a place
For our light to pass”
[Pre-Chorus]
And every fear
Starts unwinding
When you say my past
Was just practice for finding
[Chorus]
Take my hand
Welcome to my secondhand heaven
It’s a little cracked
A little torn
But it’s open
I was saving all my broken
Hoping
Hiding
Now your heart fits mine like it was always meant to
In this secondhand heaven
Every old goodbye turns into something true
In this secondhand heaven
I’m brand new
With you (yeah)
[Outro]
All the worn-out dreams and tattered edges
Every fraying thread I’m stepping into
Turn to silver stars and quiet blessings
In this secondhand heaven
I’m brand new with you